New York Giants extending Joe Schoen is a Giant mistake
The NFL saw a flurry of major contracts handed out Thursday. After the Los Angeles Rams rewarded their quarterback with a massive new deal, the New York Giants made a more puzzling decision. Reports indicate the Giants extended general manager Joe Schoen.
The move raises legitimate questions. Wanting stability alongside a new head coach makes sense. Extending a general manager whose tenure has largely disappointed is a different story.
Some fans and media members blame the previous coaching staff for the regression following the team’s 2022 playoff run, but that does not absolve Schoen of responsibility. MORE: Matthew Stafford gets big pay in limited time left with Los Angeles Rams Schoen’s tenure has featured questionable roster management, shaky coaching decisions, and several costly missteps. The Giants appear to have prioritized organizational stability over accountability.
Instead of an extension, the remainder of Schoen’s contract arguably should have served as a prove-it period. New York Giants general manager Joe Schoen speaks at the NFL Scouting Combine. Mandatory Credit: Kirby Lee-Imagn Images His first two draft classes have already raised concerns.
The Giants used three first-round picks during that stretch, and none have consistently met expectations. Evan Neal has struggled with injuries and eventually changed positions. Deonte Banks was benched last season, while reports suggest Kayvon Thibodeaux could be on the trade block.