Who was Commanders' most questionable pick in 2026 NFL Draft?

At the conclusion of the 2026 NFL Draft, NFL insiders, analysts, experts, and members of the media began assessing how each team's draftees fit with their new teams. As we take a deep dive into each team's draft class, there are always picks that feel questionable. CBS Sports recently named one questionable pick for each team, and it wasn't hard to determine the Washington Commanders ' most questionable pick.

Washington Commanders: QB Athan Kaliakmanis, Rutgers (Round 7, No. 223 overall) Kaliakmanis was the pick, by default, because general manager Adam Peters did an excellent job over these three days. The Rutgers quarterback played his best football in his final collegiate season, so perhaps there are even better days ahead.

As indicated in their reasoning, Adam Peters' draft selections were very much on point in 2026. Linebacker Sonny Styles in round one, Antonio Williams (WR) in round three, edge rusher Joshua Josephs in round five, Kaytron Allen (RB) and Matt Gulbin (C) in the sixth round, and finally, Kaliakmanis in the seventh. The latter is the one piece the Commanders may not have actually needed, but perhaps Peters has a plan for him.

The Commanders' roster as a whole is improved after free agency moves and the draft. They have new offensive and defensive coordinators, and it legitimately feels like everyone is on the same page. Not just with player personnel, but with the entire plan for 2026.