Nicholas Singleton rookie RB fantasy outlook and impact on teammates

The Titans selected Nicholas Singleton in the fifth round of the NFL draft. What is his realistic 2026 fantasy outlook, and how might his presence impact Tony Pollard and Tyjae Spears? This is a terrific landing spot for a rookie running back with three-down bell cow abilities.

Singleton was never a true workhorse at Penn State, but he has four years of solid-workload experience -- and not too much of a workload to worry that he’s overextended. Tennessee has an ascending offense and two starter-caliber running backs. However, both Pollard and Spears enter 2026 with yellow flags.

Pollard is now 29 years old and on the cusp of the downside of his career. He will be overvalued this summer because he’ll have been so productive in an otherwise fantasy-unfriendly Tennessee offense. He had 300+ touches in 2023 and 2024, hitting 275 last year.

While he’s capable of handling high volume, he’s in the final year of his contract, and it’s hard to imagine this franchise re-upping with a 30-year-old free agent who will want starter money. There’s a path where the rebuilding Titans reduce Pollard’s workload to see what they have in Singleton. Spears also is headed toward free agency.