WWE SmackDown Results: Pat McAfee Is Randy Orton’s Mystery Caller

Pat McAfee returned to WWE as Randy Orton's accomplice WWE Randy Orton’s Mystery Caller | Key Points Pat McAfee turned heel and was revealed to be Randy Orton’s mystery accomplice on the April 3, 2026 broadcast of SmackDown in Orton’s hometown of St. Louis, Miss. McAfee delivered a low blow to Rhodes and helped Randy Orton lay out the Undisputed WWE champion.

“The Rams left town, the Blues aren’t gonna make the playoffs, the Cardinals are ass…” said McAfee in a heel promo. Beginning on the March 20, 2026 broadcast of SmackDown, Randy Orton was seen on a phone call with a mystery figure. Social media conspiracy theories ranged from Cowboy Bob Orton to Vince McMahon.

Randy Orton will face Cody Rhodes in the main event of WrestleMania 42, Night 1. Pat McAfee Turns Heel And Buries WrestleMania 42 Ticket Sales Pat McAfee was revealed as Randy Orton’s mystery accomplice, cutting a heel promo on St Louis about how he doesn’t like the direction of the WWE with “two 5’5 guys doing a 45-minute Iron Man match for 10 weeks straight when Randy Orton is around. ” McAfee exclaimed his surprise that tickets to WrestleMania are somehow available, and mentioned SmackDown’s recent nosedive in ratings for the episode where Rhodes regained the WWE Championship.

“I’m the one on the phone telling Randy Orton he needs to kill everything! ” said McAfee in a profanity laced promo. “[Randy Orton] is gonna save the f—ing business!