Pat McAfee challenges ex-Colts QB for criticism of Fernando Mendoza
Dan Orlovsky's contention that Ty Simpson (who has the same agent) is better than Fernando Mendoza drew a spirited response from 'Pat McAfee Show' crew
Former Indianapolis Colts quarterback Dan Orlovsky has raised some eyebrows around the NFL with his proclamation that Ty Simpson is the best quarterback in the 2026 NFL Draft. And that includes Fernando Mendoza , who led Indiana football to a national championship, winning the Heisman Trophy along the way. Orlovsky — one of ESPN 's leading football analysts — discussed his contention on the " Pat McAfee Show .
" Orlovsky said Simpson had more impressive performances than Mendoza in the biggest games, and asked McAfee when Mendoza outplayed Simpson. McAfee panelist and former Colts defensive back Darius Butler chimed in: "The College Football Playoff ! " Orlovsky got defensive in a hurry: "Am I not allowed to have an opinion and ask questions?
" McAfee responded: "So the College Football Playoff is a big mockery, a scam. ... These games just don't matter.
What are the biggest games? " Orlovsky pointed out that IU trailed Ohio State after three quarters in the Big Ten championship game: "Six points through the first three quarters. " NFL Draft is approaching: How Fernando Mendoza stacks up vs.